This tale has been filmed so many times -- and opinion seems to vary wildly as to who is the definitive Scrooge -- but this is, as far as I know, the first talkie version -- an A-list production by a major Hollywood studio with something of a B-list cast. Before I go any further I shall stake my claim that Alastair Sim in 1951's "Scrooge" (just to confuse matters, called "A Christmas Carol" in the States) nails the role perfectly, with the right combination of humbug eventually morphing to humanity. I know that some people feel that George C. Scott in the 1984 production is superior (no way, Jose) and goodness knows there have been all manner of riffs on the subject since -- female Scrooge, black Scrooge, black female Scrooge, musical Scrooge, ad nauseum.
This early black and white production is hardly faithful to the novel with various minor changes, but it is still a totally satisfying endeavour. Scrooge is played here by character actor Reginal Owen, a frequent face in dozens of 30s movies, but almost never as a lead. His lean and stooping frame is perfect for the part and he certainly makes a brave effort. Gene Lockhart in the role of Bob Cratchitt is far too plump to be believable, but he too seems to welcome a meatier role. The rest of the cast is relatively minor, although there are early parts for Leo G. Carroll as Marley's Ghost and a very young Ann Rutherford also puts in an appearance. While this movie will never supplant the 1951 version in my affections, it is a totally acceptable contribution to one's Christmas viewing. Owen's conversion may appear far too abrupt, but the viewer is still left with the necessary seasonal glow.
1 comment:
I agree that Alastair Sim is now and forever shall be the definitive Scrooge and
then some though, in something of a riff on the story, Bill Murray doesn't do too
badly
Post a Comment